The Best Thing to Do as a Photographer is to Stick Up for Your Rights

The above photo was taken by Jeremy Brooks, a friend of mine and very talented and prolific photographer. Like me, Jeremy shoots daily and his travels take him in many of the places in the City where I spend time as well.
So I was disappointed to see the photo above posted to Jeremy's Zooomr Stream. The photo above is of a shopkeeper in the Tenderloin District who literally pushed Jeremy's camera when he was trying to shoot the store. The thing is that the man has no legal authority to prohibit Jeremy from taking photographs from a public sidewalk and as such is imposing himself on Jeremy's Constitutional rights of free speech.
I get told not to take photos of things in public constantly. Pretty much every single week. Sometimes it's by guys like this. Other times its by security guards. Sometimes it's just by random people on the street. Sometimes it's by asshole cigar store owners named Anto Kamarian. I try to assess each situation individually, but where I can, I try to be polite but insist on my right to shoot. I do this because most people don't. Most people cave. And I think it's important that people like Jeremy and others stand up for their rights to shoot from public places.
It takes guts to take a photo of someone when they are pushing themselves on you and stepping all over your rights, but I'm glad Jeremy took the photo above. It helps to get the message out and make the guy above look like an ass. I'm not sure where this is but if I see the same store in my travels out walking I'll be sure and stop by to shoot a bit there myself.
People like the guy above need to learn that they can't hassle photographers for doing what is their right to do. And they don't learn this lesson because 95% of the time people just acquiesce and give into authority that they assume but don't actually hold.
Do you want to make the world a better place for others out there who are shooting with you? Then do like Jeremy did and stand up to bullys like the guy above.
You do have to be safe though too. If you are out there, especially all alone, and some crazy whacked out guy on drugs starts giving you crap, every so often you just need to cave and walk away. This photography thing of ours isn't worth getting killed over. But when you can, I'm glad to see people like Jeremy sticking up for their rights.




37 Comments:
While I agree with your sentiments Thomas, you sound somewhat militant. Yes, you have rights as a photographer, yes that guy shouldn't be pushing anyones camera gear around. But perhaps he isn't aware of the law, perhaps his reaction is symptomatic of the society we live in. The media is constantly shoving crap down our throats and conspiracy theories are rife. This guy obviously has never had anyone point a camera at his store before (and, when you think about it, THROUGH the window of his store -- he doesn't know the photographer was photographing the neon) and he reacted badly. Perhaps if someone pointed out that "hey, it's OK. I just like your neon dude!" He might have been a bit different.
Taking someone picture while they're asking you not to would also serve to annoy someone too -- regardless of your rights to do so.
Here is a quick link about the subject. It is a document reviewing the rights of a photograher
http://daughtercrow.deviantart.com/art/The-Photographer-s-Rights-16045668
Here is another legal guide. It prints up quite well in pamphlet form.
http://www.krages.com/phoright.htm
Correction: the link I posted is the original site to the one brandon listed. Sorry about that.
While I agree with your sentiments Thomas, you sound somewhat militant.
Militant about insisting on Constitutionally guaranteed rights? You bet. The problem is that most people are not militant enough. If someone touches my gear I'm taking their photo and publishing it.
Mike, ignorance of the law is no excuse!
I'm the photographer that took the shot. Let me add some details.
While I do insist on my rights, I do it in a civil manner. When the owner (I am assuming he is the owner, he may have been an employee as well) asked what I was doing, I politely said "Oh I'm just taking a picture of the neon. I collect pictures of neon signs." The vast majority of the time, people understand. They might think I'm a little weird, but sometimes they will even say "Hey we have some neon inside too, come shoot it."
In this case, a simple explaination of what I was doing didn't work. This guy was extremely rude. He insisted that I could not take a picture of anything in the window, or through the window, without his permission. I told him that I would not go INSIDE his store, but I did have the right to shoot from a public place.
Perhaps he doesn't understand the law. Perhaps his reaction is symptomatic of the lousy neighborhood that I was in. Regardless, he does NOT have the right to push me or my gear, and his militant reaction was after I explained politely what I was doing.
As far as taking his picture, if he would have been polite to me, there would have been no reason to take his picture. When this picture was taken, he was already annoyed, and he had already assaulted me. So you can bet I'm going to get a picture and put it on the net.
Related and perhaps relevant - my recent experience: http://jswfotografie.blogspot.com/2007/09/how-i-was-detained-for-taking-pictures.html
damn. Jeremy should carry around a can of MASE just to freak fuckers like that out or to actually use it if things get out of control. If someone tried to start shit with me I would just punch the fucker right in the nose and then take a picture :)
It never ceases to amaze me that there are people who will criticize you for defending the rights of photographers.
I will say what the people who criticize you should be saying: Thank you.
Just yesterday, in the forums for modelmayhem.com, I stumbled into a discussion begun by a guy who had a run-in with self-important park police. He was shooting photos of a friend of his in a public park -- a park paid for, maintained and owned by "we the people" who pay taxes. The park ranger, as you'll guess, insisted that he could not take photographs in the park.
In the multi-page meandering debate that followed the initial post, it was just amazing and frustrating how many photographers were vocally taking sides against their own rights and their own livelihood.
Few people stand up for the rights of photographers, and even photographers themselves will argue venomously against their own rights and their own best interest.
I'm not sure why this is, except maybe that some are committed to political beliefs or social philosophies which hold respect for authority and obedience above all else. I don't get it.
I've been following your blog for a while, and I really appreciate your approach to and defense of the legality of photography -- you've certainly raised awareness of the issue and are a bit of a rallying point for photographers who may have had their rights trampled on in the past.
That said, sometimes it seems like exercising your rights can get in the way of being a nice person. I have the constitutional right to do all sorts of things that I refrain from due to common decency, politeness, or favors asked. The argument of "this is America, I can do whatever I want" that I so frequently employed as a child isn't quite as cute in a grown adult. You're totally right that nobody has the legal authority over you to stop you from taking pictures of their shop, and certainly nobody should put a hand on you or your equipment, but they do have the right to ask you not to take pictures, and you have the freedom to listen and do as they ask as a favor if the mood strikes.
Just something to think about.
anonymous above has a point about people having the right to ask that his place not be photographed. But that's the whole thing...it's ASK. from what Jeremy says happened, the owner was not asking him, he was telling him...I believe, and I may be wrong, but if the shopkeeper wasn't so rude, and been more respectful of Jeremy's rights as a photographer, Jeremy prolly would have put his camera away. No harm, no foul.
While TH and Jeremy are in the right, there are so many nut buckets in the world that standing up for all our photographic freedoms may get someone hurt. TH mentions assessing the situation, but you're trying to read a person you've never met before and have no idea what they are capable of or what's stuffed into their wasteband under their shirt. Protect your rights, but also protect your ass and feel free to walk (and blog the details) away before someone gets hurt.
PS For example, that one security guard incident a few months ago was very alarming and I'm glad it didn't escalate even more - he was on some sort of power trip and felt justified in his actions.
Thomas:
I'm curious, you seem to see this issue in black and white. Who's side would you be on if Jill Greenberg took her pictures from a public sidewalk?
I like the idea of "just because you can doesn't mean you should". If this guy was rude and pushed and complained, I understand the desire to shoot him and his store. But what if he politely asked you not to take the photo. It's his right to ask and yours to ignore his request, but why not "not" take it. It's not like there is a shortage of signs out there.
Yes you can shoot photos all you want, I do, and I love having the right to, but I DO believe that my right to take pictures does not mean I have to, or should always take the shot.
It's not the "militant" part that's a problem. It's the rudeness.
Nobody should have to ask not to be photographed. It is an imposition on someone else, a violation of their privacy, to take their picture. It is up to you to ask permission.
While you and other paparazzi and stalkers have a legal right to take photographs in public, decent, kind, civilized, polite people ASK permission FIRST, and respect that when someone doesn't want a photo taken.
You and your kind of militant photographers were never taught those basic principles of civility that the rest of us learned in kindergarten. That's why you get hostile reactions from others: you are violating the social contract that allows us to all live together in close proximity, even if we don't like each other.
The best thing to do to a rude photographer is stick his camera up his ass so he can shoot his own head.
Hi Thomas,
I'm from the Netherlands,and we take a pretty liberal view on doing things you like to do, as you will probably know,.... but as always, these things are about common decency. I think one should ask for permission and, when permission is not granted, to assess the situation whether it is worth the trouble to stand on your civil rights. If not so, just don't take the image. This view I take as a photographer
By the way: being a Dutch sollictor/lawyer I also take this view.
regards,
Wim
www.wimvanes.wordpress.com
BTW, please take note that the law is not the same across the world. For example, I know that in the province of Quebec (Canada), it's not legal for newspaper to publish "non-news" pictures of people without proper authorization (hence the "file photo" you see a lot).
After reading all the comments, I would have to say that the posts describing ‘rudeness’ and ‘civility’ strike a chord in me. I would agree that since you have the ‘right’ to do something, doesn’t mean that you always ‘should’ do it. Sometimes civility and common courtesy are what is called for. As a Canadian, many people know (and we are often gently parodied for it) we are an extremely polite people. I do a lot of business and pleasure travel in the US and one thing that always sticks out is that Americans wear their ‘rights’ as chips on their shoulder. It is too bad, because it often seems to cause conflict where none is really necessary.
When I read your stories (such as the one above and of the cigar owner), I am often reminded of the time my wife and I waited in line for a tour of your ‘Capital Building’ in Washington. As we and many other people waited in line, some very obese and grubby individual approached with a bullhorn. He started blaring at us that this building was inhabited by evil men. “Do you know there are fags inside there?” he blarted (at a very high volume though is bullhorn.) “Do you know that they have anal sex with each other in their offices? God has dammed these people to Hell and he will throw YOU in Hell too for going in there and condoning these Satanic acts”. He then proceeded to get even more crude. Several people motioned to the policeman standing there and asking if he could make the individual stop… for God’s sake there were children in the line. The policeman shrugged his shoulders and said, “Sorry, but it is his right of free speech to do so..”
Please forgive me for saying this, but reading though your posts, I cannot escape the parallels drawn between you and that “bullhorn guy”. Some people may be scared and confused and perhaps not privy to all the ‘enlightenment’ that you and your colleagues have.
But damn them eh, it is your ‘right’ to do as you wish! (insert very sad, somewhat sarcastic smiley face here)
Cheers.
Glenn
anonymous begins:
It's not the "militant" part that's a problem. It's the rudeness.
And ends with:
The best thing to do to a rude photographer is stick his camera up his ass so he can shoot his own head.
Sometimes, the jokes just write themselves.
i just think that in these days of paparazzi exploiting the first amendment, i think photogs should choose their battles. I don't know why the guy didn't want his picture taken, maybe it was a religious thing. I think that if he was an important political figure or there was a point to taking the picture in the first place it would be one thing, but just to take it to take it is silly. I know they need to fuzz out people who don't give permission to being filmed, how is that so much different?
logo design
website design
web design
商标设计
wow gold
cheap wow gold
buy wow gold
world of warcraft gold
wow gold
cheap wow gold
buy wow gold
world of warcraft gold
百度排名
runescape
runescape money
runescape gold
buy runescape money
buy runescape gold
google排名
maplestory mesos
dofus
dofus kamas
dofus kamas
google左侧排名
lotro
lotro gold
lord of the rings online
lord of the rings online gold
百度推广
lotro
lotro gold
lord of the rings online
lord of the rings online gold
guild wars gold
guild wars gold
guild wars gold
guild wars
guild wars
guild wars
介绍一家翻译公司|地区优有上海翻译|秀专业深圳翻译|深圳翻译公司|提供深圳同声传译 |同声传译|和无线导览|同传设备租赁|珠海翻译|能佛山翻译|在惠州翻译汕头翻译 三亚翻译东莞翻译深圳无线导览|口译|翻译公司非常好的翻译公司|北京翻译公司|同声传译|同传设备出租|来的会议设备租赁同声传译同传设备出租|有|hao上海翻译公司|北京翻译公司|广州翻译公司
深圳翻译公司|新疆租车|翻译公司|
深圳翻译|
深圳翻译公司|
英语翻译 |
日语翻译|
法语翻译|
德语翻译|
俄语翻译|
藏语翻译|
韩语翻译
泰语翻译|
越南语翻译|
印度语翻译|
瑞典语翻译|
印尼语翻译|
阿拉伯语翻译
马来西亚语翻译
菲律宾语翻译|
意大利语翻译|
爱尔兰语翻译|
柬埔寨翻译
土耳其语语翻译|
西班牙语翻译|
葡萄牙语翻译|
外语翻译|
小语种翻译|
外语翻译|
lotro gold
lord of the rings gold
lord of the rings online gold
lotro gold
lord of the rings gold
lord of the rings online gold
Warhammer gold
Warhammer online gold
Warhammer money
War gold
War money
Tabula Rasa Credit
lotro gold
lord of the rings gold
lord of the rings online gold
lord of the rings online gold
lord of the rings gold
Tabula Rasa Credit
World of Warcraft gold
PotBS Doubloon
Pirates of the Burning Sea Doubloon
PotBS Gold
Pirates of the Burning Sea Gold
lotro gold
lord of the rings gold
lord of the rings online gold
Tabula Rasa Credit
Warhammer gold
Warhammer online gold
PotBS Doubloon
PotBS gold
Age of Conan gold
Age of Conan gold
Pirates of the Burning Sea gold
Pirates of the Burning Sea Doubloon
hy
wow power leveling
wow power leveling
wow power leveling
wow power leveling
wow powerleveling
wow powerleveling
wow powerleveling
wow powerleveling
wow gold
wow gold
world of warcraft power leveling
world of warcraft power leveling
wow power level
wow power level
power leveling wow
power leveling wow
power leveling wow
powerleveling wow
powerleveling wow
cheap wow power leveling
Maple Story mesos
MapleStory mesos
ms mesos
mesos
SilkRoad Gold
SRO Gold
SilkRoad Online Gold
eq2 plat
eq2 gold
eq2 Platinum
EverQuest 2 Platinum
EverQuest 2 gold
EverQuest 2 plat
lotro gold
lotr gold
Lord of the Rings online Gold
Rolex Replica
Replica Rolex
ネットショッピングで簡単募金
!いつものECサイトからご利用いただけます
野生動物
人権問題
医療支援
盲導犬
国際協力
自動車保険 比較
自動車 保険 見積
自動車保険.netでは、ユーザーの皆様にとって最適な自動車保険を選んでいただくために自動車保険の基礎知識、各自動車保険サービスをご紹介しております
家事代行 東京
クレジットカード
海外旅行保険
クレジットカード 海外旅行保険知らないと、ホント損します!海外旅行保険は、なんと一生タダで入れます!必見!の裏ワザです
水虫,人には知られたくない、頑固な水虫水虫や足の臭い。お客様にご満足いただける品質と対応でト
カード決済クレジットカード決済・インターネット決済代行ならJ-Paymentクレジットカード決済 クレジットカード決済 コンビニ決済(払込票) 電子マネー。
カラコン
RC 住宅
ペット 宿ペットと泊まれる宿Wans Styleは、ペットと一緒に旅行を楽しんでいただく為のサイトです。当社は各種広告の企画・デザイン制作・印刷・
看板 製作まで、どのメディアにも精通しています。
自動車教習所 東京北豊島園自動車学校∥東京都練馬区にある広いコースの自動車教習所
カップリングパーティー1対1で落ち着いてゆっくりお話できる少人数制のプチお見合いパーティーです。
ジュエリー通販ジュエリー総合通販サイト。人気商品多数取り扱い!
除菌天然素材だから、忘れがちなまな板や包丁の
ータルプロデュースいたします。
渋谷エステビューティーサロンダイエットNARL超音波とEMSマシーンで痩せたい所をスリムに!更にタラソマスクで身体の代謝を高め美肌に。
アロママッサージ六本木マッサージ忙しい現代では、「感じる」心や体も滞りがちですfeel」はストレスを脱ぎ捨て、息づく生命力と心身の五感を呼び覚ます。賃貸住宅/アパート・
派遣
引越
ローン
ショッピング枠 現金化
レジットカード 現金化
外国為替
ローン
ローン
マンション・一戸建て価格検索.
賃貸
不動産
結婚相談所、東京・大阪・名古屋を中心に全国の結婚相談所を徹底比較できます。
価格比較.比較購入-どけち.com日本最大級の価格検索・
価格比較購入サイトですparty、パーティー、ローン比較! このサイトは各社
ローンを比較して、申し込みすることができます
ソフトウェア販売ソフトウェア.ソフト.価格比較.価格検索.比較購入-どけち.com
コンピューターPC.パソコン関連.価格検索・価格比較・比較購入-どけち.com
デジタル カメラ電気製品.家電.価格検索・価格比較・比較購入-どけち.com
家具電気製品.家電.価格検索・価格比較・比較購入-どけち.com
ファッション 通販電気製品.家電.価格検索・価格比較・比較購入-どけち.com
ゲーム
パーティー結婚準備|結婚相談所|結婚情報
出会い結婚準備|結婚相談所|結婚情報
国際結婚結婚準備|結婚相談所|結婚情報
結婚式場結婚準備|結婚相談所|結婚情報
結婚準備結婚準備|結婚相談所|結婚情報キャッシング/
カードローン‐金利で選ぶ -ローン比較ローン金利比較-賢いローンの選び方
住宅ローン
まとめローンおまとめローン(無担保) -ローン比較
キャンピングカーCAR.車.価格比較.価格検索.比較購入-どけち.com
国内格安航空券航空券.格安航空券.価格比較.価格検索.比較購入-どけち.com
結婚結婚準備|結婚相談所|結婚情報|パーティー|partyを選ぶなら結婚に関する情報を提供します-
フィットネスクラブフィットネス クラブ と スポーツ 用品のおすすめ
wow power leveling
wow power leveling
wow power leveling
wow power leveling
wow powerleveling
wow powerleveling
wow powerleveling
wow powerleveling
wow gold
wow gold
world of warcraft power leveling
world of warcraft power leveling
wow power level
wow power level
power leveling wow
power leveling wow
power leveling wow
powerleveling wow
powerleveling wow
cheap wow power leveling
Maple Story mesos
MapleStory mesos
ms mesos
mesos
SilkRoad Gold
SRO Gold
SilkRoad Online Gold
eq2 plat
eq2 gold
eq2 Platinum
EverQuest 2 Platinum
EverQuest 2 gold
EverQuest 2 plat
lotro gold
lotr gold
Lord of the Rings online Gold
Rolex Replica
Replica Rolex
hy
wow power leveling
wow power leveling
wow power leveling
wow power leveling
wow powerleveling
wow powerleveling
wow powerleveling
wow powerleveling
wow gold
wow gold
world of warcraft power leveling
world of warcraft power leveling
wow power level
wow power level
power leveling wow
power leveling wow
power leveling wow
powerleveling wow
powerleveling wow
cheap wow power leveling
Maple Story mesos
MapleStory mesos
ms mesos
mesos
SilkRoad Gold
SRO Gold
SilkRoad Online Gold
eq2 plat
eq2 gold
eq2 Platinum
EverQuest 2 Platinum
EverQuest 2 gold
EverQuest 2 plat
lotro gold
lotr gold
Lord of the Rings online Gold
Rolex Replica
Replica Rolex
hy
Buy cheap WOW Power Leveling,sell wow gold.welcome to buy cheap wow gold-We can have WOW PowerLeveling,buy wow gold game, World Of Warcraft Gold,wow Gold, world of warcraft gold deal,Cheap WOW Gold. Welcome here to buy the professional World Of Warcraft Power Leveling service, World Of Warcraft PowerLeveling for Cheap Wow Powerleveling, WoW Power leveling Guide.
Alcohol Tester purchasing center is a professional enterprise Breathalyser,Breathalyzer specializes in breath Gas Alarm consulting,Gas Detector through internet.Co Detector,Co Alarm always have been designed to alarm.
济南市龙威液压机械有限公司是专业生产液压升降机,是国内领先的升降机及升降平台的生产厂家。RAID数据恢复是“Redundant Array of Independent Disk”的缩写,中文意思是独立冗余磁盘阵列。另外还有数据恢复、服务器数据恢复等恢复方式。
“加密狗“的工作原理?加密狗内置单片机电路(也称CPU),使得加密锁具有判断、分析的处理能力,增强了主动的反解密能力。我们致力于提供一流的同声传译设备租赁服务,在同声传译领域,同声翻译设备租赁具备一流的新一代博世会议设备租赁服务。
google排名让您通过网络成就搜索引擎优化未来。众多网站优化的客户实践看来,google左侧排名效果非常理想。其中seo效果最好的要属google左侧排名,google优化是网络营销的有力推广方式搜索引擎排名!
太陽光発電
治験
ウィークリーマンション
人材派遣
防犯カメラ
不動産担保ローン
看護師 求人
介護
看護師
会社設立
特許事務所
キャッシング
不動産
ローン
医師 募集
横浜中華街
害虫駆除
バイアグラ
キャッシング
転職
メル友
自動車ガラス
カラコン
パイプカット
ダイビング
EC サイト構築
ウェディングドレス
ウェディング
有料老人ホーム
葬儀 東京|
医師 求人
医師 転職
医師 募集
永代供養
永代供養
永代供養
家庭教師
人材紹介
アトピー
ペット 求人
広告業界
美容学校
データ 復旧
美容整形 東京
月経困難症
マンションリフォーム
住宅リフォーム
スカッシュ DVD
イメージコンサルタント
カラーコーディネーター
会社設立
就職ナビ
アダルトグッズ
アンチエイジング 化粧品
アメリカ ビザ
マッスルトレーナー
ウォーキングシューズ
サウナスーツ
マンスリーマンション 東京
納骨堂
弁理士
基礎化粧品
[url=http://www.baidu.com]Good luck for you[/url]
Good luck for you
太陽光発電
不動産担保ローン
介護
看護師
会社設立
特許事務所
キャッシング
不動産
横浜中華街
害虫駆除
バイアグラ
転職
メル友
自動車ガラス
治験
ウィークリーマンション
カラコン
ダイビング
EC サイト構築
ウェディングドレス
ウェディング
医師 求人
医師 転職
医師 募集
有料老人ホーム
葬儀 東京|
家庭教師
アトピー
永代供養
永代供養
永代供養
人材紹介
ペット 求人
広告業界
美容学校
データ 復旧
美容整形 東京
月経困難症
マンションリフォーム
住宅リフォーム
スカッシュ DVD
イメージコンサルタント
カラーコーディネーター
会社設立
就職ナビ
アダルトグッズ
アンチエイジング 化粧品
アメリカ ビザ
マッスルトレーナー
ウォーキングシューズ
サウナスーツ
マンスリーマンション 東京
納骨堂
弁理士
基礎化粧品
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home